menu Home

“This Universe Existed before The Big Bang” ft. Roger Penrose

Beeyond Ideas | March 13, 2024
"This Universe Existed before The Big Bang" ft. Roger Penrose


This post currently has 44 comments.

  1. @flona7955

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    singularity dont exist only in the big bang but also in the black hole, but when a star collapses in itself why did it created a black hole instead of a big bang? since the big bang and the black hole has a singularity?

  2. @JeffGarrett-ou9xs

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    This guy is correct cuz you must have a room to put all the stuff into in the first place, it's just like an empty apartment and you are moving in, inan other univers or I should say another room that is full of furniture is all being recycled by a black hole and is being transfered into the new apartment, is that hard to figure out

  3. @grande6075

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    Time and space cannot have a beginning and an end, simply because they cannot be created, just an space is difined as nothing ,nothing cannot be created because simply put why in this world that you created something that has no physical state. Time in the same manner is a passage of moment its hard to imagine that time doesnt move even to the a quadtrillion of a second or to trillion smallest division of time. Time and space existed without begg. and end, it will go on forever and ever.

  4. @craigyanta8482

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    Expansion seems to be a "local" event as is the "big bang" in my opinion. The size of existence is unimaginable. I don't believe mathematics are the key in other than local events.

  5. @mcrypto874

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    What if the very very old black hole was so dense and full of everythink from what ended in her that this THE black hole and explods and this the big bag for us. Maybe this particular black hole was unique and this the big bang.

  6. @Gumby07

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    A amazing thought could be a replay of our human experience being replayed over and over using a blank consciousness being replayed with same or different outcomes because you can’t get something from nothing .
    It might be something that some call a soul !
    I find it possible and amazing

  7. @jameswood3168

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm


    Astronomers and scientists don't even know what a galaxy is and yet they like to pretend they know all about it.

    A brief description follows.

    A galaxy is made of two discs of stars separated by a black rift. Why are they separated? The obvious answer is, because they are different.

    The theory of the Expanding Universe was created before Anti-matter was even thought of, So, let us assume that is the answer,

    Magnetism has attracted the two sides of the galaxy to one another, but they haven't destroyed one another because the opposing gravities created by their masses, is pushing against each other is keeping them apart. The result is they begin moving through space. A gravity reaction engine has been born, and if Einstein is right the speed of light has been tossed on the trash heap and the many dimensions existing behind Its curtain suddenly have been revealed to us.


    That's because we watch a universe that is accelerating and think that it iis expanding.

    {One half of every galaxy is made up of matter as we know it, while the other half is made up of anti-matter. The black hole that we are observing at the center of all galaxies is what a Gravity Reaction looks like. Einstein said, the mass of an object increases in direct proportion to its speed so as a Galaxy's speed increases so does its mass. As mass increases so does Gravity. So because the Galaxy is being powered by Gravity there is no reason why it should ever stop accelerating, and because the galaxies were all created at different times our Universe appears to be expanding. If you could put a tiny Galaxy in a magnetic bottle to power a spaceship you'd have to wonder were there little worlds and tiny beings evolving in there, and if there were what happened to them when (WARP DRIVE?) was engaged.}

    speed is the curtain that hides dimensions from us. Like looking in a barber shop mirror; Universes stretching out to infinity, but Not seen by us because they are going more than one light speed faster or slower than we

    You see at the center of the galaxy is the visual sign of a Gravity Reaction.


    Here’s an idea that could be the solution. It’s been rattling around in my head since the mid-sixties. .

  8. @leonardgibney2997

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    I've always believed in the infinite. About twenty years ago the BBC science unit conducted an experiment using the microwave background radiation to see whether the universe is unbounded or bounded in the four dimensions using the microwave background radiation. The result was indeed a universe unbounded in the three dimensions of space and one of time. It did not begin and has no edge they said.

  9. @SSTan-cz7eo

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    The expansion ,remain stationary and then contracting and finally exploding of the universe had been described in detail in the Buddhism sutra more than 2500 years ago.Check the word " KALPA ".
    A sutra even describe the appearing of gods , also known as devas of which there are many many ( millions )

  10. @RickMason-yj7pv

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    I came up with the idea a fully loaded black hole was the singularity for our universe…time after time, snd other black holes exploding create the multiverse. So far no one has told me why or even if I am wrong.

  11. @AlexisOmnis

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    Is this how entangled particles communicate? Can they bend space & even time in higher dimensions, meaning they experience no spacial or temporal distance from each other?

    And, with this same principal, could the expansion of space be an illusion, so that particles with mass are the only objects that see & experience the expansion of space?

  12. @louisgiokas2206

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    One of my biggest problems with current cosmological theories is that they are based on simulations that do not reflect what we observe. Specifically, the simulations that give us the big bang are based on quantum mechanics and particle physics. The problem here is that they do not include, or explain, dark matter or dark energy. Considering that by current measures dark matter makes up five times as much stuff as the "normal" matter that is described by the standard model, this seems like a glaring problem.

    The way simulation in science is supposed to work is that one takes a theory, simulates what should happen in an experiment according to that theory, or observation, and then uses the results of the experiment to tend to prove or disprove the theory. Notice, there is no absolute proof here.

    Given that, all of the theories and simulations that we have of how the universe evolves are failures. The simple fact is that they say nothing about what 25% of the matter in the universe is or where it came from, makes them (I know I am sort of repeating myself, but it needs emphasizing). Of course, if you want to support the standard model, then you probably have to give up on dark matter. So, which is it?

  13. @brunosantos321

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    And I saw the dead—the great and the small—standing before the throne. The books were opened, and another book was opened—the Book of Life. And the dead were judged according to what was written in the books, according to their deeds. The sea gave up the dead that were in it, and death and Sheol gave up the dead in them. Then they were each judged, each one of them, according to their deeds.

    Then death and Sheol were thrown into the lake of fire. This is the second death—the lake of fire. And if anyone was not found written in the Book of Life, he was thrown into the lake of fire.

    Revelation 20:12-15

    (Tree of Life Version)

    This is eternal life, that they should know you, the only true God, and him whom you sent, Jesus Christ.

    John 17 : 3 a

    For if you forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. But if you don't forgive men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses.

    Matthew 6 : 14

  14. @DaneDuPlessis

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    This stuff tickles the ears wonderfully, but please be warned that without putting in several years of rigorous study it’s very easy to imagine oneself more understanding and knowledgeable than one really is.

  15. @Nivola1953

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    This is not a really good video, it name drops, but instead of letting the real scientists talk, they come out with pearls like at 2:10, “ …. A singularity followed by the EXPLOSIVE Big Bang…”. Explosive, like a bomb going off in air? WTF, double scientific WTF. Calling the expansion of space an explosion is like calling “sh*t hitting the fan” a modern art moment. I stopped watching and banned this channel not worth the algorithmic attention.

  16. @Nivola1953

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    See some comments below with lots of 👍🏽, about how they don’t believe the Big Bang, because “come on, it doesn’t make sense”. Oh yeah, “Common sense physics”. 🙄🤷🏻‍♂️ The refuge of all conspiracy theorist and “believers”. What sense can you make of particle-wave duality, of quantum tunnelling and Eisenberg indetermination principle, and yet here we are “arguing” on devices that exists because we, or actually some other smarter humans, understand how those ideas to be factual descriptions of the subatomic world behaviour.

  17. @hiskiamartin805

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    I am puzzled and fascinated at the same time. If when we view in the distance galaxies we are looking at the past?! then where can we look to see the present. Then again, where can we point the Webb telescope to view the future. is our galaxy the centre or judging from the movements of the galaxies where are they all coming from, or are they like the bubble screen saver of the desktop. can you show us that point? if we are the present. please show a galaxy that's in the future as it emerges. I believe if we can see the past so then can we see the future.

  18. @jaunasbonniface340

    March 13, 2024 at 7:12 pm

    The universe is like a seed, its develop and grow into a big tree and then the big tree die. And another seed is grow into another big tree. This scenario keep on going and going. This is not the first universe and not the last one.

Leave a Reply

play_arrow skip_previous skip_next volume_down